According to the published criteria, we should have done well. Somehow we managed to score lower than Alexandria on "rotation" which is odd because Wikimania has never been held in the Southern Hemisphere.
I'd have liked too see the IRC log from the judges meeting, to see where we lost our points, but of course that isn't going to happen, so we'll have to work it out ourselves, by comparing the bids.
In retrospect, our bid wasn't that great. We were pinning more hopes on our location, and Cape Town's attractions, then on the bid itself. It was expensive, last-minute, and lacking sponsership & good accommodation. By losing, we got our chance to get it right next time.
The good news, is bidding opens for Wikimania 2009 almost immediately. I don't know what the chances are of 2009 being in Africa again, but I'm assuming we are going to bid, if everyone can pick themselves up and get going on it. To do it, w e are going to need firm sponsors. Find any friends you have corporate contacts, and twist their arms.